The New York Yankees are facing a roster dilemma as spring training gets underway, with pitcher Marcus Stroman making it clear that he is unwilling to transition to the bullpen. Yankees manager Aaron Boone has responded to Stroman’s comments, emphasizing that while decisions regarding the rotation and bullpen aren’t imminent, the team remains confident that the situation will work itself out.
Stroman, who signed with the Yankees before the 2024 season, is a veteran starting pitcher with a track record of reliability and success. However, with a deep Yankees rotation that includes Gerrit Cole, Max Fried, Carlos Rodon, Clarke Schmidt, and Luis Gil, Stroman’s role has come under question. Despite speculation about a potential bullpen role, Stroman has unequivocally stated, “I’m a starter. That’s who I am.”
Stroman’s Stance: No Bullpen Move
Marcus Stroman’s declaration about his role has been a talking point among Yankees fans and analysts. The right-hander has built his career as a starter, known for his durability, ground-ball-inducing style, and ability to command the mound effectively. During an interview, Stroman was direct when asked about the possibility of moving to the bullpen:
“I’m a starter. That’s how I prepare. That’s what I do. My routine, my mindset, my work—all of it is structured around being a starter. I don’t see myself as anything else.”
His firm stance is understandable, given his history. Over his career, Stroman has been a workhorse for multiple teams, including the Toronto Blue Jays, New York Mets, and Chicago Cubs. The 32-year-old signed a two-year, $37 million contract with the Yankees in the offseason, with an $18 million salary for 2025 and a vesting option for 2026 if he reaches 140 innings pitched this season.
Aaron Boone’s Response: A Measured Approach
When asked about Stroman’s comments, Yankees manager Aaron Boone acknowledged the complexities of the team’s pitching situation but remained diplomatic in his response.
“The situation is what it is. We talked today, and he’s in a good headspace. He’s physically prepared, and we’re just getting him ready to pitch. These things often sort themselves out.”
Boone’s response suggests that while Stroman’s role isn’t set in stone, the Yankees are not pressing the issue just yet. The team’s rotation depth gives them options, and Boone appears willing to let circumstances dictate how things unfold.
The Yankees’ Rotation Dilemma
The Yankees boast a deep and talented rotation, arguably one of the best in Major League Baseball. The front office has made it a priority to build a formidable pitching staff, and the presence of multiple high-quality arms means that some difficult decisions lie ahead.
Here’s a look at the projected starting rotation:
- Gerrit Cole – The ace and reigning AL Cy Young winner is locked in as the Yankees’ top starter.
- Max Fried – Acquired in a blockbuster trade, Fried provides another elite arm at the top of the rotation.
- Carlos Rodon – After an injury-plagued 2023, Rodon is looking to bounce back and solidify his place.
- Clarke Schmidt – A homegrown talent, Schmidt showed promise last season and is expected to be a key contributor.
- Luis Gil – A young, electric arm who has impressed in limited action.
With this lineup, Stroman finds himself as a potential sixth starter. While a six-man rotation is possible, it is uncommon and would require strategic planning regarding innings and rest days. If the Yankees opt for a traditional five-man setup, someone will have to move—whether to the bullpen or potentially another team.
Could Stroman Be Traded?
Another possibility is that the Yankees could look to move Stroman before the season begins. While the team has not openly shopped him, there have been murmurs that his name has come up in trade discussions. Given his experience and contract structure, Stroman could be an attractive piece for teams in need of a solid mid-rotation starter.
However, trading Stroman comes with risks. The Yankees would be losing valuable depth in their pitching staff, and injuries could quickly change the team’s needs. Boone and the Yankees front office will likely weigh all options carefully before making any final decisions.
Stroman’s Value to the Yankees
Despite the uncertainty, Boone made a point to emphasize Stroman’s value to the team.
“The reality is, Marcus might be the most important starting pitcher for us this year,” Boone said. “We need depth, and he provides us with that.”
Stroman’s ability to eat innings, limit home runs, and keep his team in games makes him an asset. His experience in high-pressure situations is also valuable, especially as the Yankees aim to make a deep postseason run.
Clubhouse Dynamics: Is There Tension?
Any time a player publicly asserts their role, questions about clubhouse chemistry arise. However, Boone has downplayed any potential tension, emphasizing that Stroman is focused and professional.
Boone also noted that players often have strong opinions about their roles, which is a natural part of competitive sports. What matters most is how the team moves forward collectively.
The Yankees’ Path Forward
As spring training progresses, the Yankees will need to address their rotation situation. Several factors could influence their decision-making:
- Health of Other Starters – If an injury occurs, Stroman’s place in the rotation could be cemented.
- Performance in Spring Training – If Stroman outperforms others, he could secure a starting role.
- Bullpen Needs – If the Yankees feel they need an additional high-leverage reliever, a Stroman move to the bullpen might be reconsidered.
- Trade Market – If the right trade opportunity presents itself, the Yankees might consider moving Stroman.
Conclusion
Marcus Stroman has made it clear that he sees himself as a starter, and Yankees manager Aaron Boone has acknowledged his stance while taking a patient approach to the situation. With a stacked rotation and limited spots, the Yankees have a tough decision ahead.
As the season approaches, the situation will likely resolve itself, whether through injuries, performance, or strategic decisions by the front office. Boone remains confident that whatever happens, the Yankees will be in a strong position moving forward.
For now, all eyes remain on Stroman and the Yankees as they navigate this early-season challenge. Whether he remains in the rotation, moves to the bullpen, or is traded, Stroman’s future will be a key storyline for the Yankees in 2025.
Leave a Reply