Cowboys Crash Out of Top 20 in End-of-Season SI NFL Power Rankings

The 2024 NFL season was a tumultuous journey for the Dallas Cowboys, culminating in their fall out of the top 20 in Sports Illustrated’s end-of-season power rankings. This decline reflects a season marred by injuries, inconsistent performances, and significant organizational changes. This article delves into the factors contributing to the Cowboys’ disappointing season, analyzing key moments, player performances, and the broader implications for the franchise’s future.

A Promising Start Derailed

The Cowboys entered the 2024 season with high expectations, ranked No. 10 in the NFL.com Power Rankings. They commenced the season with a victory over the Cleveland Browns, suggesting a positive trajectory. However, the optimism was short-lived. By Week 4, the team was plagued by injuries, notably to quarterback Dak Prescott, who suffered a season-ending right hamstring injury after playing just eight games. Prescott’s absence was a significant blow, as he had recorded 11 touchdown passes and eight interceptions before his injury.

---

The Injury Plague

Injuries extended beyond Prescott, affecting multiple key players and positions. The offensive line, already integrating rookies Tyler Guyton and Cooper Beebe, faced additional challenges due to the lack of veteran depth. The defense also suffered, with linebacker DeMarvion Overshown’s injury exemplifying the team’s struggles. These setbacks disrupted team cohesion and performance, contributing to a 7-10 overall record and a dismal 2-7 home record.

Coaching Turmoil

The underwhelming season prompted significant coaching changes. Head coach Mike McCarthy was dismissed after five seasons with the team. Brian Schottenheimer, who had served as the offensive coordinator for the past two seasons, was promoted to head coach. This decision was met with skepticism from franchise legends. Emmitt Smith, the NFL’s all-time leading rusher, expressed his concerns, stating that the move “doesn’t feel good” and emphasizing the need for a clear and committed vision to avoid repeating past mistakes.

Rookie Contributions

Amid the challenges, the 2024 rookie class was thrust into pivotal roles. Offensive linemen Tyler Guyton and Cooper Beebe were starters from the outset, facing a steep learning curve. Linebacker Marist Liufau stepped up following Overshown’s injury, showcasing potential despite the team’s overall struggles. Defensive lineman Marshawn Kneeland and cornerback Caelen Carson also saw increased playing time, gaining valuable experience that could benefit the team in the future.

Power Rankings Decline

The Cowboys’ performance fluctuations were mirrored in the power rankings throughout the season. After their initial victory, they experienced a steady decline. By Week 10, the team’s freefall was evident, and they continued to slip in subsequent rankings. The culmination of these struggles was their omission from the top 20 in Sports Illustrated’s end-of-season power rankings, a stark contrast to their preseason expectations.

Statistical Overview

A closer examination of the season’s statistics reveals areas of concern:

• Offense: The team struggled to maintain consistency, especially after Prescott’s injury. The running game was ineffective, and the offensive line’s instability contributed to a lack of protection and run support.

• Defense: The defense faced challenges in maintaining leads and preventing big plays. Injuries and inexperience in key positions led to lapses that opponents capitalized on.

• Special Teams: While kicker Brandon Aubrey had an impressive season, converting 36 of 38 field goal attempts, including all 10 from beyond 50 yards, the overall special teams unit faced inconsistencies that affected field position and momentum.

Looking Ahead

As the Cowboys transition into the offseason, several critical decisions loom:

• Coaching Strategy: With Brian Schottenheimer at the helm, the team must establish a cohesive strategy that addresses the shortcomings of the previous season. This includes reassessing offensive schemes and defensive alignments to better suit the players’ strengths.

• Player Development: Investing in the growth of the 2024 rookie class and integrating them effectively into the team’s core will be essential. Providing these young players with the necessary support and training can help build a more resilient roster.

• Free Agency and Draft: Identifying and acquiring talent to fill critical gaps, particularly in the offensive line and defensive backfield, will be paramount. Strategic moves in free agency and the draft can bolster the team’s competitiveness.

Conclusion

The 2024 season was a challenging chapter for the Dallas Cowboys, marked by unmet expectations and significant hurdles. However, with adversity comes the opportunity for reflection and growth. By addressing the underlying issues and making informed decisions, the Cowboys can aspire to reclaim their status as a formidable force in the NFL. The journey ahead requires resilience, strategic planning, and a unified commitment to excellence.